The opinion of the court was delivered by: Legge, Justice.
This is an action for personal injuries alleged to have been sustained by the plaintiff, an infant, as the result of a collision in Marlboro County between an automobile in which plaintiff was riding and which was being operated by his father, and a tractor-trailer owned by the defendant Wyman D. Powers, which was being operated by the defendant Fred Edward. The action was commenced in Marion County, where both defendants resided; and thereafter plaintiff moved before the Honorable G. Badger Baker, Judge of the Twelfth Judicial Circuit to change the place of trial to Marlboro County upon the ground that the convenience of witnesses and the ends of justice would be thereby promoted. From Judge Baker's order dated July 7, 1956, granting said motion, the defendants appeal.
The complaint alleged, in substance, that the collision occurred about 8:00 a. m. on August 19, 1955, at Coxe's Cross Roads, some eight miles south of Bennettsville, the county seat of Marlboro County; that at this point South Carolina Highway SC-35-50, on which the tractor-trailer was traveling in a westerly direction, is intersected by a county road, on which the automobile was traveling in a northerly direction; that numerous obstructions "such as weeds and other growth" at said intersection prevented the driver of the automobile from seeing the approach of a motor vehicle traveling on SC-35-50; that the driver of the automobile in which plaintiff was riding approached the intersection, came to a complete stop, and then attempted to traverse the intersection; and that thereupon the tractor-railer, which was being operated negligently and recklessly in respect of excessive speed and failure of its driver to keep a proper lookout and to give warning of its approach, struck the right side of the automobile, causing the plaintiff to be severely and permanently injured.
The answer of the defendants admitted the allegations as to plaintiff's minority, his father's appointment as guardian ad litem, residence of the respective parties, ownership of the tractor-trailer, and agency of its driver; that a collision between the two vehicles had occurred at the time and place alleged; and that at said intersection there were weeds and growth; denied the remaining allegations of the complaint; and alleged that the collision resulted from the negligence and recklessness of plaintiff's father in operating the automobile without adequate brakes, in failing to obey the "stop" sign at said intersection, and in failing to look or otherwise exercise due care.
William C. Goldberg, Esq., of counsel for the plaintiff: That the accident occurred in Marlboro County at Coxe's Cross Roads, which is the intersection of Highway SC-35-50 and the road leading from the Hunt's Bluff road to the Salem Road; that from his investigation it appears that approximately eleven witnesses. all residents of Marlboro County, will be called to testify for the plaintiff as to the material facts of the accident, the conditions existing at said intersection at the time of the accident and immediately thereafter, the manner in which the plaintiff was injured, and the extent of his injuries; that all of the persons involved in the accident were taken to Marlboro County General Hospital at Bennettsville; and attended by doctors who reside in Bennettsville; that all of the law enforcement officers who investigated the accident reside in Marlboro County; that all of the witnesses to the accident, other than the defendant Fred Edward, live in Marlboro County and reside approximately forty miles from the Court House at Marion, and it would greatly inconvenience them if they were required to leave their work and attend trial there, whereas if the case were to be tried at the Court House in Bennettsville they could attend on brief notice, testify, and return to their duties with a minimum loss of time; that it will be highly advisable for the jury to view the intersection where the accident occurred, and that if the case is tried in Marlboro County such view could be accomplished with less trouble, expense, and loss of time than if the trial were had in Marion County; that the plaintiff and his family are people of small means and are not in position to pay the additional expense incident to trial in Marion; and that a Marlboro County jury, being acquainted with or having knowledge of all of the witnesses other than the defendant Fred Edwards, would be in better position to weigh their testimony than would jurors of Marion County.
Mrs. Louise J. Jackson: That she is the plaintiff's mother, and a necessary witness, having been involved in the accident; that she has seven children, some of whom are very young and require her constant care and attention; that she is now (the affidavit is dated September 21, 1955) pregnant and expects to give birth to a child in about four months; and that it would be most inconvenient for her to attend trial at Marion because of its distance from her home, whereas if the trial were had at Bennettsville she could attend upon short notice, testify, and return to her home and children with minimum loss of time.
Earl Jackson: That he is the plaintiff's father, and was driving the automobile at the time of the accident; that trial at Marion would be inconvenient to him because of its long distance from his home and work, and because he has no automobile, but that if the case were tried in Bennettsville he would be able, without great expense, to obtain the necessary transportation from his home to the Court House there; and that he is financially unable to provide transportation to Marion for the other members of his family who are necessary witnesses, but could obtain, from friends and neighbors, transportation for them to Bennettsville.
Raymond Woodle: That he resides in Marlboro County, and is manager of the Carolina Theatre at Bennettsville, and also is a commercial photographer; that he was requested some time ago (his affidavit is dated September 21, 1955) to visit the intersection known as Coxe's Cross Roads, about eight miles south of Bennettsville, and to take photographs of said intersection and the adjacent area; that he is advised that he will be called as a witness for the plaintiff to testify concerning the photographs taken by him; that because of his work it would be most inconvenient for him to attend trial in Marion County, but that he could attend and testify in Bennettsville with minimum loss of time from his duties.
Douglas Jennings, M.D.: That he is a physician engaged in practice at Bennettsville, and is one of the doctors who attended the plaintiff following the accident; that because of his duties it would be most inconvenient for him to testify if his case was tried at Marion; but that trial at Bennettsville would involve minimum loss of time from his duties.
John M. Freeman: Resides in Marlboro County and employs plaintiff's father to farm for him a tract of land about eight miles south of Bennettsville. Is familiar with the place of the accident, and is advised that he will be called to testify in regard to it and the adjacent surroundings and in regard to plaintiff's appearance. Is a busy farmer, and to attend trial at Marion, rather than at Bennettsville, would be most inconvenient for him.
Jack H. Whitley: Is a public engineer, residing in Bennettsville, where, in addition to his engineering work, he is employed by H.J. Munnerlyn, Inc. Has been called upon by plaintiff's attorneys to make a survey of the place of accident, and will be called to testify in regard to such survey and in regard to the topography at the intersection. To attend trial at Marion would be most inconvenient, whereas attendance at Bennettsville would involve minimum loss of time.